top of page
Search

Early Anthropic Shares and the Capital Gains Problem: Which Lots Fit a CRUT, What It Costs, and How It Compares With Selling, Holding, an Exchange Fund, and the Matched DAF

Oct 27
24 min read

Short answer. A charitable remainder unitrust lets a trust, not you, sell low-basis Anthropic shares. The trust pays no tax on the sale, reinvests the full proceeds and pays you a fixed percentage of its value every year. In a 10,000-path model of a 35-year-old Californian contributing $20 million of shares at 1% basis, the trust left the family ahead of selling and reinvesting in 95% of paths, with everything charity receives counted as a loss to the family. Against keeping the shares, the answer turns on what you expect of one stock. If it matches the market's average return, its volatility pulls its typical outcome far below the market's and the trust wins about three paths in four. If it compounds like the market on the typical path, keeping wins about two in three. RSU shares settled at the IPO, shares pledged to the donation match and money you may need to reach later do not belong in the trust.


Jurisdiction: Federal, with a California overlay for income tax conformity and community property

Primary Statutes: IRC §§ 664, 664(b), 664(c)(1), 664(d)(2), 170(b)(1)(C), 68, 4941, 4947(a)(2), 7520, 83(a), 83(b), 170(e)(1)(A), 170(f)(11)(C), 422(a)(1), 422(b)(5), 424(c)(1), 1202, 1223(2), 1259(c)(1), 2001(c), 2010(c)(3), 2036(a)(1), 2055(e)(2)(A), 2056(b)(8), 2523(g); Treas. Reg. §§ 1.664-3(a)(5), 1.664-3(b), 1.664-4, 1.61-2(d)(2)(i), 1.83-2(a), 1.83-3(e), 1.83-4(a), 1.83-7(a), 1.170A-13(c)(7)(xi)(C), 1.170A-16(d), 1.421-1(g), 1.664-1(a)(7), 1.664-3(a)(4), 20.2036-1(c)(2), 25.2511-2(c); Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §§ 17755, 17952, 18152; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, § 17951-2

Key Authorities: Rev. Rul. 78-197, 1978-1 C.B. 83; Ferguson v. Commissioner, 174 F.3d 997 (9th Cir. 1999); Rev. Rul. 2003-7, 2003-1 C.B. 363; Rev. Rul. 2026-21 (§7520 rate, November 2026); Gottlieb, Journal of Financial Planning (August 2026); Gottlieb, NAEPC Journal of Estate & Tax Planning (October 2026); Anthropic, PBC, Form S-1 (filed October 26, 2026)

Last Reviewed: October 2026

Category: Charitable Remainder Trusts — Concentrated Stock


By Klaus Gottlieb, Esq.


How to read this post


The post runs in five parts, in the order the decision runs:

  1. The issues. Which of your lots can go into a trust at all, what a sale costs, and the calendar.

  2. The opportunities. What the trust does with a low-basis lot, the age question, and a worked example with its assumptions stated.

  3. The risks. What you give up, where the model can be wrong, and what happens if the next twenty years break it.

  4. The alternatives. Selling, keeping, the donation match, an exchange fund and four others, each at its strongest.

  5. The choices that require drafting. The decisions that live in the trust document.


Three shorter routes through it:


Every number in Part 2 is labeled as known (a statute, a published rate, arithmetic) or modeled (the output of a simulation under stated assumptions).


Part 1 — The issues: what you hold decides everything


Screen each lot before anything else


Basis is what you paid for a share, plus any amount already taxed to you when you received it. A trust helps only with gain that has not yet been taxed, so the screen runs lot by lot.


Lot

Basis

Fits the trust?

Shares early-exercised with an §83(b) election, held more than a year

The price paid, usually near zero; the holding period runs from exercise (Treas. Reg. §§1.83-2(a), 1.83-4(a))

Yes. These are the best candidates, unless they are incentive stock option shares still inside the periods in the third row.

Shares from options exercised more than a year ago

Exercise price, plus any spread taxed as wages at exercise (Treas. Reg. §§1.83-7(a), 1.61-2(d)(2)(i))

Yes, if the basis is a small fraction of value.

Incentive stock option shares, early-exercised or not, within two years of grant or one year of exercise

Exercise price

Not yet. A gift before both periods run is a disqualifying disposition (§§422(a)(1), 424(c)(1)). For early-exercised shares, the one-year period runs from exercise even while they are unvested (Treas. Reg. §1.421-1(g)).

RSU shares settled at the IPO

Value at settlement, taxed to you as wages (§83(a); Treas. Reg. §§1.83-3(e), 1.61-2(d)(2)(i))

Not until they have risen well above that value and you have held them more than a year.

Unexercised options

—

No. An incentive stock option cannot be transferred during your life (§422(b)(5)), and a nonqualified option given away is still taxed to you as wages when it is exercised (§83(a); Treas. Reg. §1.83-7(a)). The shares from exercise are candidates once they qualify.

Shares pledged to the donation match

—

Give them through the match (Part 4).

Shares already committed to a sale: a trading-plan instruction, a tender

—

No. A sale already arranged is taxed to you (Ferguson v. Commissioner).


Two points behind the RSU row. Settlement at the IPO taxes the full value as wages, so the IPO price becomes your basis and there is no gain for the trust to defer until the stock rises. And a contribution of stock held one year or less measures the deduction by your basis rather than the shares' value (§170(e)(1)(A)); the trust takes over your holding period (§1223(2)), so if it sells before a year from settlement has passed, the gain is short-term and reaches you taxed at ordinary income rates.


Basis matters by degree, too. In the model in Part 2, the trust beat a sale in 89% of paths at a basis of 25% of value and in 53% at 50%. The model understates the trust at high basis: it taxes every payment as capital gain, while under §664(b) a trust funded with higher-basis shares eventually pays out principal that is not taxed at all.


One more item the prospectus settles: the Class E shares the company will issue to employees carry limited voting rights and no economic rights, and they cannot be transferred (Anthropic S-1). They stay with you and have no bearing on any of this.


Check the small-business stock exclusion first


Section 1202 can exclude all the gain on qualified small business stock held more than five years, up to the greater of $10 million or ten times your basis per company, but only for stock issued while the company's gross assets had never exceeded $50 million, before or immediately after the issuance (§1202(a)(1), (a)(4), (b)(1), (d)(1); the limit is $75 million for stock issued after July 4, 2025). Anthropic raised $124 million in its Series A in May 2021. That leaves founders' stock, and stock issued before the company passed the limit, as the only possible candidates; shares from options exercised after that point were issued too late. If you hold any candidate, have it tested before any other step: a federal exclusion can be worth more on that lot than anything in this post. California does not follow the exclusion, so the 13.3% state tax remains (Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §18152).


What a sale costs


A Californian in the top brackets pays 20% federal capital gains tax, 3.8% net investment income tax and 13.3% California tax, which treats capital gain as ordinary income: 37.1% of the gain. On $20 million of shares at 1% basis the arithmetic is fixed.


$20,000,000 of shares, basis $200,000

Amount

Gain

$19,800,000

Federal capital gains tax, 20%

$3,960,000

Net investment income tax, 3.8%

$752,400

California tax, 13.3%

$2,633,400

Total tax

$7,345,800

Left to reinvest after a sale

$12,654,200

Reinvested by the trust after its sale

$20,000,000


Bar chart. Selling $20 million of shares at 1% basis costs $7.35 million in tax and leaves $12.65 million to invest; the trust sells the same shares and invests all $20 million.
Known: arithmetic on 2026 top California rates.

The calendar


The S-1 leaves the offering date blank; CNN reports that trading could begin as soon as November 16. Employee shares do not release on one date. Under the S-1's resale schedule, non-founder directors and officers and certain current and former employees may sell part of their shares on the first trading day. Further tranches release on the 27th, 48th, 62nd and 76th days after the date of the final prospectus, then on the second full trading day after Anthropic reports its 2026 results and on five more dates over the following ten weeks. Whatever remains releases on the earlier of the second full trading day after the first-quarter 2027 results or the 180th day after the prospectus date. If trading begins in mid-November, the 27th-day release falls in December 2026 and the 48th-day release near year-end. The co-founders and certain large holders follow a separate 365-day schedule. The preliminary S-1 leaves each tranche's percentage blank, and your own lock-up or market standoff agreement controls the dates that apply to you (Anthropic S-1, “Shares Eligible for Future Sale”).


Five constraints follow.


  • The shares must reach the trust before any sale is arranged. Rev. Rul. 78-197 sets the formal line at a binding obligation to sell, and Ferguson v. Commissioner, 174 F.3d 997 (9th Cir. 1999), taxed donors where the sale had ripened to practical certainty even without one.

  • Read your lock-up agreement for its transfer exceptions. The form the S-1 summarizes permits a transfer, not for value, to a trust for the direct or indirect benefit of the holder or the holder's immediate family, if the transferee signs a lock-up agreement. It also permits bona fide gifts and charitable contributions, but withholds that exception from current and former employees and consultants who are not founders, directors or officers (Anthropic S-1, “Underwriting—Lock-up and Market Standoff Agreements”). A charitable remainder trust benefits both you and a charity, so whether it fits the family-trust exception is a reading the company and the underwriters have to accept. Get their written confirmation before transferring locked-up shares. With it, the trust can receive shares before their release and sell them when the release reaches them. Without it, the trust receives each tranche as it releases.

  • Locked-up shares need an appraisal. Shares that cannot yet be sold are not valued at the market quote: the deduction for them needs a qualified appraisal and may reflect a discount (§170(f)(11)(C); Treas. Reg. §§1.170A-16(d), 1.170A-13(c)(7)(xi)(C)). While the trust holds them, the careful course treats them as unmarketable assets, valued each year by an independent trustee or by a qualified appraisal (Treas. Reg. §1.664-1(a)(7)).

  • Keep trading-plan shares out. Anthropic has reportedly weighed requiring employees to sell through Rule 10b5-1 trading plans. Shares a plan already commits to a sale are the wrong shares to contribute.

  • A 2026 deduction requires funding by December 31, 2026. Before shares can move, the trust has to be drafted and signed, the trustee has to accept, and a brokerage account in the trust's name has to be open.


Pledged shares are a separate bucket


The S-1 describes a donation matching program: employees pledge part of their equity awards, or the cash from them, to a donor-advised fund or other nonprofit, and the company matches in shares of its nonvoting Class N stock or in cash. Anthropic reports that about half of its employees participate. For long-held shares you intend to give, the match beats any trust design: the company adds shares, a gift of stock held more than a year is deductible at fair market value within the 30%-of-AGI limit (§170(b)(1)(C)), and the gain is never taxed to anyone. Pledged shares held a year or less are deductible only at basis. The trust in this post is for the shares you keep.


Part 2 — The opportunities


How the trust works


You transfer shares to an irrevocable trust. The trust is exempt from income tax (§664(c)(1)), so it sells the shares without tax and reinvests the full proceeds. Each year it pays you a fixed percentage of its value, revalued annually, of at least 5% (§664(d)(2)). The trust's term, meaning the period during which it pays, can be one or more lives, a fixed period of up to 20 years, or the longer of a life or 20 years (Treas. Reg. §1.664-3(a)(5)). Your payments carry the deferred gain out to you under the ordering rules of §664(b), so you pay the tax as you receive the money rather than at the sale. When the term ends, what remains passes to the charities you name. At funding you receive an immediate income tax deduction for the calculated remainder value, computed at the §7520 rate for the month of funding or, if you elect, either of the two preceding months (§7520).


Why youth helps


My study in the Journal of Financial Planning counted every dollar that reached charity as a dollar the family lost and still found the trust ahead in many scenarios. Horizon was among the strongest levers. For the study's baseline couple, ages 63 and 65 with basis at 20% of value, seven additional years of horizon raised the probability of beating the hardest alternative from 28.2% to 96.4%. The study charged every alternative a 1% annual cost and 20% annual turnover. The model below charges the alternatives less, which favors them, so its results against keeping the shares are lower than the study's.


Too young?


Not for a trust that runs for a fixed term; age plays no part in whether a term trust qualifies. Age matters only when a life sets the term, because the charity's share, valued at funding, must be at least 10% of what you contribute (§664(d)(2)), and a younger life means longer expected payments and a smaller charity's share. The deciding question is whose life sets the term. Both spouses can fund the trust while one spouse serves as the measuring life and receives the payments, which support the household.


Design (November 2026, §7520 rate 6.2%)

Qualifies from age (5% payout)

Highest payout at 35

Highest payout at 45

20-year term

Any age

11.29%

11.29%

Your life alone

28

5.98%

7.97%

Longer of your life or 20 years

29

5.66%

6.98%

Both lives, spouse one year younger

40 (older spouse); 39 if the same age

Does not qualify

5.68%


Known: computed under Treas. Reg. §1.664-4 with payments at the end of each quarter. At 35 and 34, a trust measured by both lives leaves the charity 8.1% of the gift and fails.


Line chart of the highest qualifying CRUT payout by age at the November 2026 section 7520 rate of 6.2%, payments at the end of each quarter. A single-life trust qualifies from age 28, the longer of a life or 20 years from age 29, and two lives from age 40 for the older spouse. At 35 the limits are 5.98% and 5.66%.
Known: Treas. Reg. §1.664-4, payments at the end of each quarter.

The CRT Age Check Calculator runs the same test for your ages at the current rate.


A worked example, with its assumptions stated


The example is an employee, 35, married to a spouse of 34, both California residents. The employee contributes $20 million of shares held more than a year at a basis of 1% of value. The trust pays 5.5% a year for the longer of the employee's life or 20 years; if the employee dies within 20 years, the spouse receives the payments for the rest of that period. The 5.5% rate sits below the 5.66% ceiling for this design.


The model is the engine behind my Journal of Financial Planning study; under the tax law the study modeled, it reproduces the study's published results exactly. It runs 10,000 paths. A path is one simulated future of market returns and the employee's lifespan, and the same paths drive the trust and each alternative. For every path it computes the present value, at 5% a year, of everything the family receives after tax: payments, the tax value of the deduction and whatever heirs inherit. Charity's share counts for nothing.


Input

Value

Known or modeled

§7520 rate

6.2%, November 2026 (Rev. Rul. 2026-21)

Known

Charity's share at funding

10.61% of the gift, payments at the end of each quarter: deduction $2.12 million

Known (computed)

Tax rates

37.1% on gains and on every trust payment

Rates known. Taxing every payment as long-term gain is the study's convention; in practice the trust's interest and dividends come out first at their own rates, and at higher basis later payments include untaxed principal (§664(b)).

Deduction limits

30% of AGI with five-year carryforward; 0.5%-of-AGI floor; §68 limitation; AGI $1.5 million a year

Rules known; AGI modeled

Diversified portfolio (the trust's, and a seller's)

7% expected return, 12% volatility, lognormal; 0.25% annual cost; median compound growth after cost 6.1%

Modeled

Kept shares

No cost. Three cases: market-level risk (12% volatility, same paths as the portfolio); a single stock with 35% volatility, correlation 0.5 with the portfolio and the same 7% expected return; the same single stock with an 11.4% expected return, enough to match the portfolio's median compound growth

Modeled

Taxable turnover

5% a year in a seller's portfolio; none in kept shares. The published study charged every alternative, kept shares included, 20% annual turnover and a 1% annual cost. Under that convention the trust here comes out ahead in 96% of paths against selling, 95% against keeping and drawing the same income and 89% against keeping until death, compared with 95%, 8% and 7% when kept shares with market-level risk bear no turnover or cost. Shares you simply hold incur neither, so this post does not charge them.

Modeled

Payments

Paid each year on the trust's value at year end (a model simplification; the trust revalues once a year on its valuation date)

Modeled

Lifespan

Sampled per path from the 2012 Individual Annuity Mortality table, projected, male; the IRS table as a sensitivity

Modeled

Estate tax

Not modeled (see below)

Omitted

Reproducibility

10,000 paths; market seed 42, mortality seed 4242, single-stock seed 4343

—


The three alternatives:

  • Sell and reinvest: sell everything now, pay $7.35 million of tax, invest the rest in the same diversified portfolio as the trust, and draw 5.5% a year.

  • Keep and draw: keep the shares, sell enough each year to draw the same 5.5%, and leave the rest to heirs, whose basis is adjusted to value at death.

  • Keep until death: keep every share, draw nothing, and leave everything to heirs on the same terms.


Bar chart of how often the trust leaves the family ahead across 10,000 simulated paths: 95% against selling and reinvesting. Against keeping the shares and drawing the same income: 8% if the shares carry market-level risk, 73% if they are a single stock with the market's expected return, 38% if the single stock compounds like the market on the typical path. Against keeping every share until death: 7%, 76% and 35%.
Modeled. Employee 35, $20 million at 1% basis, longer of life or 20 years, 5.5% payout.

Trust compared with

Kept shares with market-level risk

Single stock, same expected return

Single stock, same median growth

Sell and reinvest

Ahead in 95% of paths; median +$3.40M (10th percentile +$1.17M, 90th +$7.02M). The held-stock assumption does not apply.

Keep and draw

Ahead in 8%; median −$1.67M (−$6.78M, −$0.09M)

Ahead in 73%; median +$5.07M (−$14.6M, +$12.8M)

Ahead in 38%; median −$4.41M (−$82.4M, +$7.82M)

Keep until death

Ahead in 7%; median −$22.8M (−$94.9M, −$1.70M)

Ahead in 76%; median +$10.0M (−$40.1M, +$18.6M)

Ahead in 35%; median −$18.4M (−$572M, +$12.3M)


Modeled. Differences are the trust's family present value minus the alternative's, at 5% a year; 10th and 90th percentiles in parentheses. The trust's median family present value is $15.26 million.


Three findings come out of the table.


Against selling, the trust wins on 95 paths in 100. It invests $20 million where a seller invests $12.65 million. The payments carry the deferred gain out to you as taxable income, but the tax not yet paid stays invested in the meantime. The result stayed between 88% and 97% of paths across every sensitivity in this post except two: a basis of half the shares' value (53%), and capital gains taxed as ordinary income after the trust is funded while the seller paid today's rates (68%).


Against keeping, the result depends on what you expect of one stock. At 1% basis, a holder who sells only what he spends defers the same tax the trust defers, and each dollar drawn carries about 37 cents of tax either way. The kept shares cost nothing to hold, while the trust's portfolio costs 0.25% a year, and the trust's deduction, worth $0.93 million in present value, is offset by an inheritance that goes to charity instead of heirs. If one stock behaved like a diversified portfolio, keeping would win on more than nine paths in ten.


A single stock does not behave like a diversified portfolio. With 35% volatility, a stock whose expected return equals the market's 7% compounds at a median of only 1.4% a year, against 6.1% for the portfolio, because volatility it is not paid for drags its typical outcome down. In that case the trust comes out ahead on about three paths in four. For the stock to compound like the market on the typical path, its expected return has to be about 11.4% a year. Grant it that, and keeping wins on about two paths in three. Which case describes Anthropic stock over the next several decades is a judgment the model cannot make for you. The first is the standard assumption for one company's stock; the second assumes the market will pay you for carrying that company's risk. The trust is a way to diversify without paying the tax first. If you expect your shares to compound like a diversified portfolio, you have no reason to diversify and no reason for the trust.


The trust wins the typical path; keeping can still win the average. In the single-stock case with the market's expected return, keeping every share until death leaves heirs a median of $3.30 million in present value against the trust's $15.26 million, yet an average of $46.1 million against the trust's $16.4 million. A minority of paths in which the stock compounds far above its median carries the average. Which of the two numbers should govern is a question about your own appetite for risk.


What the model leaves out. Estate tax is not modeled. Shares kept until death, and the portfolio a seller leaves, form part of your taxable estate; above the federal exemption, $15 million per person in 2026, the excess is taxed at up to 40% (§§2010(c)(3), 2001(c)). If you die still receiving payments, the trust is counted in your estate (§2036(a)(1); Treas. Reg. §20.2036-1(c)(2)), but the charity's remainder is deductible (§2055(e)(2)(A)) and a spouse's successor interest qualifies for the marital deduction when the spouse is the only other noncharitable beneficiary (§2056(b)(8)), so the trust itself adds no tax. Leaving the tax out favors the alternatives, keeping every share until death most of all.


What the family and charity receive


Line chart of the after-tax payment from the trust over 40 years. The median is about $736,000 in the model's first year and $761,000 in year 20, or about $476,000 at 2026 prices; the 10th to 90th percentile band widens over time.
Modeled. Median and 10th–90th percentile of trusts still paying. The model pays on year-end value, so its first payment exceeds the $692,000 fixed at funding.

  • Payments. The first year's payment is fixed at funding: 5.5% of $20 million, $1.10 million before tax and about $692,000 after it (known). Later payments follow the trust's value. The portfolio's median compound growth after cost, about 6.1%, slightly exceeds the 5.5% payout, so the median payment rises slowly in dollars: $761,000 after tax in year 20, or $476,000 at 2026 prices with 2.5% inflation (modeled).

  • Deduction. The immediate income tax deduction for the calculated remainder value is $2.12 million (known). Spread over the year of the gift and the carryforward years within the 30% limit, its tax value is $0.93 million in present value (modeled).

  • Early death. On 2.6% of paths the employee dies within 20 years. The spouse then receives the remaining payments until year 20, worth $3.47 million in present value on average across those paths (modeled). The design is the subject of my paper How a Young Donor's CRUT Keeps Paying After an Early Death.

  • Charity. The median trust runs 57 years and hands charity $22.4 million in the dollars of that year, or $1.60 million in present value at 5% (10th to 90th percentile: $0.47 million to $5.78 million) (modeled).


What moves the result


Dot plot of the share of paths with the trust ahead under seventeen single changes to the base case. Against selling, the trust stays between 88% and 97% except at 50% basis (53%) and if gains are later taxed as ordinary income (68%). Against keeping a single stock with the market's expected return, 60% to 83%. Against kept shares with market-level risk, under 1% to 40%.
Modeled. One change at a time from the base case.

One change from the base case

vs. sell and reinvest

vs. keep and draw, single stock

vs. keep and draw, market-level risk

Base case

95%

73%

8%

IRS mortality table (2010CM)

88%

69%

4%

Payout 5.0% instead of 5.5%

94%

73%

7%

Basis 10% of value

94%

72%

2%

Basis 25% of value

89%

70%

<1%

Basis 50% of value

53%

67%

<1%

Measuring life 30 (5.0% payout)

96%

72%

7%

Measuring life 40 (5.0% payout)

92%

70%

6%

Measuring life 45 (5.0% payout)

88%

68%

4%

Federal gain rate 25% after funding

94%

72%

9%

Gains taxed as ordinary income (39.6% federal) after funding

68%

72%

11%

Expected return 5%

95%

60%

40%

Expected return 9%

94%

83%

<1%

Portfolio volatility 18%

95%

69%

24%

Portfolio cost 1% a year

95%

68%

<1%

Dies 7 years sooner than sampled

92%

69%

5%

Lives 7 years longer than sampled

97%

73%

12%


Modeled. Share of 10,000 paths with the trust ahead. "Single stock" means 35% volatility, correlation 0.5 and the market's 7% expected return. Tax changes apply to everything realized after funding; the seller in the first column paid today's 37.1%. Against keeping every share until death, the single-stock results run from 70% to 80% across these rows.


To run the same comparison on your own lots, ages and basis, QuantiCRUT provides the suitability framework from the study in software.


The deduction and the IPO year


A gift of long-held stock to a trust whose remainder goes to a public charity is deductible up to 30% of AGI, with five years of carryforward (§170(b)(1)(C)). Gifts of stock through the donation match draw on the same 30% limit, so if both land in the IPO year they compete for one ceiling. The 0.5%-of-AGI floor and the §68 limitation, both effective in 2026, trim the value at the margin; §68 holds the federal value of the deduction to about 35 cents per dollar for top-bracket filers. A trust funded in December 2026 and one funded in January 2027 produce nearly the same deduction. The difference is which year's income it offsets first and how much of the ceiling your matched gifts have already used.


Funding in stages


A trust drafted to accept additional contributions (Treas. Reg. §1.664-3(b)) matches staggered releases: draft once, then add shares as tranches release. Each addition is valued on its own date and earns its own deduction at the §7520 rate for that month.


Control of the portfolio


You can serve as trustee, subject to the valuation condition above while the trust holds locked-up shares. The trustee sells the shares when the lock-up allows and invests under the trust's investment policy, which can be the same index-fund policy you would use yourself. If you serve while employed, the trust's sales fall under the insider trading policy and its trading windows, as your own sales do. The self-dealing rules that apply to private foundations reach the trust (§§4941, 4947(a)(2)): no loans, purchases or other transactions between the trust and you or your family.


Income that does not depend on a job


The payment arrives whether or not you work. For someone weighing a move to lower-paid research, public-interest or nonprofit work, the trust converts a single stock into an income base that is revalued each year and lasts for life, without the 37% a sale would take first.


Part 3 — The risks


You cannot reach the principal


The transfer is irrevocable. You receive the annual percentage and nothing more: no withdrawal for a house, a startup or a change of plans. This is the most common reason people who run the numbers decline the trust, and it is a sound one for any money you may need. Size the trust to the shares you would otherwise hold for decades.


When the trust loses


Part 2 shows where: against keeping, when one stock compounds like the market on the typical path; against a sale, when basis is a large share of value or when gains are taxed far more heavily after funding. In those cases what charity receives is a real cost to the family, and only a charitable objective justifies it.


Early death


A trust measured by a life ends when that life ends. The longer-of design keeps payments going to the successors you name until 20 years from funding. In the example the guarantee costs 0.32 percentage points of payout ceiling at 35: 5.66% instead of 5.98%.


If you expect the next twenty years to break the models


Four inputs carry most of the result, and each can move in a direction you may consider likely.


  • Returns. If a diversified portfolio earns 9% a year instead of 7%, the trust still beats a sale on 94% of paths and beats keeping a single stock with the same expected return on 83%; against kept shares with market-level risk, it almost never wins. At 5%, it beats kept shares with market-level risk on 40%.

  • Volatility. If the diversified portfolio itself swings 18% a year, the trust wins against kept shares with market-level risk on 24% of paths and leaves the comparison with a sale unchanged.

  • Lifespan. Payments measured by a life last as long as the life. Seven extra years lift the trust to 97% of paths against a sale. The deduction is fixed at funding on the IRS table and does not change.

  • The tax regime. Rate increases after funding fall on the payments. If capital gains became taxed as ordinary income, the trust would still beat a sale made today on 68% of paths. A holder who keeps every share until death escapes the income tax through the basis adjustment at death, a rule that is itself subject to change.


A prearranged sale


Rev. Rul. 78-197 sets the formal line at a binding obligation to sell; Ferguson v. Commissioner taxed donors where the sale had ripened to practical certainty without one. Contribute first; let the trustee decide on the sale afterward.


The trustee's obligations


The trust files Form 5227 every year, keeps the records that sort each payment into its tax character, and obeys the self-dealing rules. A trust of this size bears these costs easily, but the duties do not end.


Leaving California


California follows the federal rules for these trusts (Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §17755), and its 13.3% rate makes the deferral worth more here than in a state without an income tax. If you move during the payout term, the state tax on later payments needs its own residency analysis.


Diversification is a decision


Nothing requires the trust to sell. A trustee who keeps the shares keeps the concentration risk, and the trust's payments then rise and fall with one stock. The case for the trust in this post assumes the trustee diversifies.


Part 4 — The alternatives, each at its strongest


Alternative

Tax result

What you give up

When it wins

Sell and reinvest

37.1% of the gain, now

The tax

You may need the principal, or the basis is high

Keep and draw

Tax on each sale; heirs' basis adjusted at death; estate tax above the exemption

Diversification

You expect the stock to compound at least like the market on the typical path

Keep until death

No income tax in life; gain erased for heirs at death; estate tax above the exemption

Diversification and income

The goal is the largest possible inheritance and you accept one stock's risk for decades

Donation match

On shares held more than a year: gain never taxed; deduction at fair market value within the 30% limit

The shares

Shares you meant to give: the company's match multiplies the gift

Exchange fund

Gain carried into the fund interest

Control of the portfolio; access for about seven years; no income

Diversification only, with no income need, no charitable interest and a plan to hold until death

Collar or prepaid variable forward

Deferred if the hedge stays outside the constructive-sale rules (§1259(c)(1); Rev. Rul. 2003-7)

Upside above the cap; dealer costs

Only if your insider trading policy permits hedging; public-company policies commonly prohibit hedging and pledging

Gradual sales with loss harvesting

Spread over years; offset by losses harvested elsewhere

Years of single-stock exposure

A modest position relative to your other assets

Moving out of California before selling

Can remove the 13.3% on a sale after a genuine change of residence, since a nonresident's gain on stock is generally not California income (Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code §17952); compensation earned in California stays taxable there (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 18, §17951-2)

California

You were moving anyway

Small-business stock exclusion

Federal gain excluded on qualifying stock; California taxes it

Nothing

Founders' stock and the earliest-issued stock, if it qualifies


When the donation match wins. For any long-held share you intended to give, the match decides the question. The company adds shares, the gift is deductible at fair market value and the gain is never taxed. A trust remainder reaches charity decades later and earns a deduction for only its calculated value today.


When the exchange fund wins. An exchange fund keeps the wealth yours. You contribute shares to a partnership and receive an interest in a pooled portfolio, which the sponsor runs under its own mandate. Funds customarily expect you to stay about seven years and pay nothing in the meantime. Hold the interest until death and the basis adjustment can erase the gain, though the interest is then part of your taxable estate; spend the money during life and you meet the gain again. It is the better answer when diversification is the only goal. The full comparison is in Saving Capital Gains Tax on SpaceX Stock.


One fact specific to you. Your salary, your unvested awards and your shares all depend on the same company and the same industry. A diversified portfolio is the only one of your assets that does not, which raises the value of diversifying above what the model in Part 2 assumes.


The alternatives do not exclude each other. One position can be divided lot by lot among the match, a trust, an exchange fund and an outright sale.


Part 5 — The choices that require drafting


The model answers whether a trust can work. The document determines whether it does what your family needs. These are the choices it has to make, and each one is a decision about your family rather than a form to fill in.


  • Whose life, and which term. A term of years, one life, two lives, or the longer of a life or 20 years. A recipient paid for a life must be paid for his or her own life, so a spouse who is not a measuring life can receive payments only within a term of years, as in the longer-of design. At your ages the measuring life is usually one spouse, chosen with the payout and the 10% test in view.

  • Who receives the payments after you. A spouse as the only successor keeps the gift within the marital deduction (§2523(g)); children as successors protect the family against a common accident but create gifts that the document has to address, often through a retained power to revoke their interests by will, which the regulations permit and which keeps those gifts incomplete (Treas. Reg. §§1.664-3(a)(4), 25.2511-2(c)).

  • The payout rate. Set against the 10% test at the rate for the funding month, with margin for a funding date that slips.

  • Payment timing. Quarterly payments at the end of each quarter, as in this post's figures; the document has to state the timing the calculation assumed.

  • Additions and funding order. An additions clause, and which lots go in first: lowest basis, longest held.

  • Trustee and successor trustee. You, your spouse, or an institution; an independent trustee or appraiser for valuations while locked-up shares remain; and who takes over if you cannot serve. The investment policy belongs in the trustee's instructions.

  • The remainder. Named charities, a donor-advised fund as remainder beneficiary, and a power to change the charities later.

  • Community property. Who funds the trust, who receives the payments and whose consent the gift requires. See Can One Spouse Fund a California CRUT Alone?

  • The mechanics around the shares. The lock-up agreement, the insider trading policy, any trading plan, the equity administrator's transfer process and a brokerage account in the trust's name.


Frequently asked questions


Can I put RSU shares from the Anthropic IPO into a charitable remainder trust?

Not usefully at first. RSUs that settle at the IPO are taxed as wages at their value on that day, so that value becomes your basis and there is no gain to defer. A contribution within a year of settlement also earns a deduction measured by your basis, not the shares' value. They become candidates only after they have risen well above their settlement value and you have held them for more than a year.

Not for a trust that runs for a term of up to 20 years, which qualifies at any age. At the November 2026 §7520 rate of 6.2%, with payments at the end of each quarter, a trust measured by one life qualifies from age 28 at the 5% minimum payout, the longer of one life or 20 years from 29, and two lives from about 39 or 40.

In a 10,000-path model of a 35-year-old Californian contributing $20 million at 1% basis, the trust left the family ahead of an outright sale in 95% of paths, counting everything charity receives as a loss to the family. The result fell below 88% only at a basis of half the shares' value or if gains became taxed as ordinary income after funding.

It depends on what you expect of one stock. If a single stock with 35% volatility has the market's expected return, its typical outcome falls far below the market's and the trust comes out ahead on about three paths in four. If the stock compounds like the market on the typical path, keeping wins on about two in three. The trust is a way to diversify without paying the tax first.

No. For long-held shares you intend to give, the company's match multiplies the gift, the deduction is at fair market value and the gain is never taxed. The trust is for the shares you keep.


What to bring to the first conversation


  • A lot-level report from the equity administrator: grant type, exercise or settlement date, basis and share count for each lot

  • Copies of any §83(b) elections

  • Your lock-up agreement, the insider trading policy and any trading plan

  • Your ages and your spouse's

  • The income you need from these shares, and the amount you may need to reach as principal

  • Which shares are pledged to the donation match


For the age test at today's rate, use the CRT Age Check Calculator. To run the comparison on your own lots, use QuantiCRUT. To discuss your shares with me, schedule a call.


CalCRUT.com and Wealth Care Lawyer are not affiliated with or endorsed by Anthropic, PBC.


This article is general information only. It is not tax or legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Whether a lot fits depends on facts specific to each holder — grant type, exercise and settlement dates, elections filed, lock-up and trading-plan terms, and residence — and the modeled results rest on stated assumptions that will not hold exactly; offering terms, the §7520 rate and tax law should be confirmed as of the funding date. Consult counsel admitted in the relevant jurisdiction.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page